Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Roughly Rolica: the AAR

"On the morning of Thursday last my forces came upon the French who were deployed on the heights above a village named to me as Rolica.  I report that at nine in the 'fore noon we commenced operations  in a most vigorous manner with General's Hill and Craufurd's brigades attempting to take possession of the heights from the French, whilst General Nightingall and Fane's Brigades made flanking marches to left and right of the French positions respectively.  The French immediately retired not wishing, as I conceive it, to be encircled by our men.  Whilst this was occurring our Spanish allies were making a wide manoeuvre with the intent of arriving well behind the French in the vicinity of the village of Columbeira a good mile to the rear of the initial French position.   I have the honour to inform you that we were eminently successful in these endeavours and defeated the French most wholesomely on the plains betwixt the two villages with only Brenier's artillery and two much battered brigades of foot escaping the field.

Being adverted to the fact that Marshall Junot was to the south and marching with all haste towards us with his entire army and mindful of the fact that the bulk of the army was not yet disembarked from the transports we did not pursue beyond Columbeira village."

Report from Sir Arthur Wellesley to the War Office (well it's what he would have reported if he had been at our roughly Rolica game anyway).

1. An 1875 illustration of the battlefield (via Wikipedia)

On last Thursday morning I arrived at Gary's house to play a game of Valour and Fortitude.  Neither of us had played the rules before and Gary's last figure game was over forty years ago!  As a result this was very much a learning game but it did give me the chance to give my new MDF toys an airing.  We played thirteen turns between 10.30 in the morning and 6.15 in the evening with time off for lunch and much chatting and debate on aspects of the rules.  All in all I'd say we had about seven hours at the game table so an average of around thirty minutes a turn.  Gary took the British and I had the French.

All units have a fire power rating, a melee rating and a tenacity rating.  The fire power and melee rating show how many dice they roll in that type of combat and tenacity shows how many hits they can take before being at risk of breaking.  Lost tenacity points can be recovered by rallying in the action stage but this prevents them from fighting or changing formation.  Some units have special rules for their starting factors which I will detail when they come into play.

The Spanish, standing in for Trant's Portuguese, would appear on the road to Columbeira some time after turn five (in keeping with the designer's note we took each turn to be around thirty minutes).  I used a dice roll starting on turn six with each following turn giving an increasing chance of them arriving on table until the were guaranteed to appear on turn 11.  I deployed four French battalions in line on the hill above Rolica with the Swiss (who are unenthusiastic), artillery and the half regiment of Chasseurs in reserve in the dead ground below.  Unenthusiastic troops start with a one point reduction in melee and tenacity rating compared to the statistics they would normally have.

2. The initial deployments French in line British in march column

The British elected to advance in March columns to close on the French as quickly as possible (white triangles denote the head of the column).


3.  The end of turn 1 British columns approaching but still outside musket range

In the face of the approaching, and overwhelming British forces I faced two choices.  Stand and fight here on the hill above Rolica with a near certain risk of my route of retreat being cut, or make a fighting withdrawal.  If I withdrew the timing was going to be critical.  I decided to retreat but thought I could stand long enough to make the British deploy into line, which would slow their rate of advance, before I started to 'advance to the rear'!  However, I did start the Swiss infantry moving straight away while moving the chasseurs and artillery to threaten Nightingall's Brigade around Rolica.

4.  After three turns I'm in march column and retiring

With hindsight I let the British get too close before I started to withdraw forgetting that the hills are classed as rough ground for this scenario!  Rough terrain doubles movement costs, essentially negating the speed advantage of being in march columns.  At the same time I moved the cavalry out to my left wing to see if Gary would decide to form square with Nightingall's two battalions in response, which would create a nice target for my artillery.  He didn't.

5. A turn later and the French have a problem

A problem you say, damn right!  The two British Columns to the left of the hill might not cut the French off but they will be closing into musket range before the French battalions can clear the rough ground.  I should have started my withdrawal sooner.  The Swiss are well away though and after Nightingall shook his battalions out into line my cavalry and artillery decided not to contest Rolica village with no infantry support.  Still being in line will slow the British advance on my right. Its my left where I have a problem!

6. The end of turn 6 and things are not looking good for the French

Three game hours in and things are starting to go badly wrong for the French.  One of the Infantry battalions is lagging behind as they failed an activation check.  The only saving grace is that the British had an entire column fail as well so three battalions are no further forward either.  

Units can always shoot but taking any action requires the passing of an activation test.  Actions include movement, rallying of tenacity hits, and assaults.  Most units can also change formation at the start or end of their movement.

Worse yet though the Spanish have passed their entry dice roll and will begin arriving next turn!  To counter this I send the unenthusiastic Swiss racing for Columbeira village (Bottom left of image 6).  If nothing else they can act as a speed bump.  The incoming Spanish brigade consist of a Line Infantry battalion which this early in the war counts as 'unpredictable', a Light Infantry battalion which is fairly steady and a Militia battalion who are poorly trained and equipped.  The Swiss are going to struggle against them.

Each major nation has it's own army sheet detailing the troops available and any special abilities (or for some nations disabilities) their troops have.  Spanish Line Infantry have unpredictability as one trait which means that on first combat they must roll a D6 before fighting.  On a roll of one their initial factors are reduced and on a six they are increased.  Sometimes they fight like lions but other times, well, not so much!  The Militia don't have variability but can't use skirmish fire and their volleys are not as effective as those of line troops.

Elsewhere I dithered about what to do with the artillery and deployed it in the hope that I might get a couple of shots off on Nightingall's troops.  The cavalry continue to withdraw  and will eventually move to support the Swiss.

7. At the end of turn 7 and things are starting to hot up!

After three hours (game time) there has not been any significant fighting just move and counter move as the French attempt to slip away from the British.  There has been some desultory artillery fire but with no noticeable effect.  But this is about to change as one French battalion fails to activate for a second consecutive turn and stays partially in the rough ground.  Delaborde (thats me) realises his (my) gamble has failed and he must now fight at a disadvantage.  Accordingly I reform from March column into line.

V&F is an I go - U go system and uses a game sequence of Fate cards (we didn't use these in this game), then firing, then actions (which include movement and assaults) followed by resolving melees.  Then the other player cycles through the same sequence.  This forces some decisions on when to change formation (an action) as it happens after that turns firing for your side and the other player may get a chance to shoot before your next turn.

Gary has his own problems as he is also forming into line but finding that he has an issue with troop congestion and only three battalions can form a firing line.  This is as near to parity as I'm going to get.  On the British left Nightingall has taken Rolica without a fight but has no enemy within easy reach as I have bugged out!  An interesting situation now arises.  Gary has to advance his three battalions into musket range but then cannot shoot until his next turn.  So I take the opportunity to shoot with two battalions at one of his and score maximum hits and then I retire out of musket range unscathed. 

Meanwhile at Columbeira the Spanish have entered the table and deployed two battalions into line.  My Swiss battalion has reached the outskirts of the village but can't occupy the houses in the same turn.  they are now supported by the Chasseurs.

8. Turn 9 at Columbeira.  Who will win the race for the village?

Things are looking increasingly difficult for the French.  Although I have changed back into marching columns on the plain, Gary has realised that if he can keep units within 9cm of the French they can't use double movement to escape and that his rifles out range muskets so can harass the slowly retiring French columns.  It has become a foot race towards the ridge below Columbeira and even if the French get there first they will be shot to pieces as they climb the rough ground towards the crest.  That is of course assuming they get that far as the Spanish seem well placed to brush aside the Swiss and Chasseurs and cut off my line of retreat!

9.  An overview of the situation at the end of five game hours (Turn 10)

In the image above the red line is the divide between the Anglo-Spanish and French forces, while arrows show marching columns and their direction of travel.  It clearly shows one French battalion still marooned at the top of the picture having failed to activate for two consecutive turns.  The Swiss and a battered Chasseur unit are still holding off  the Spanish flank march and the bulk of the French are beating a hasty retreat.

The following turn saw the Swiss continue to a good account of themselves by breaking a second Spanish Battalion in a musket duel.  To balance that the Spanish Militia shot down the French cavalry in turn.  The French continued to head for the hills but Hampered by Gary cleverly keeping units within 9cm to stop the use of doubling.

One of the available actions is 'Doubling' which allows any unit a move of double distance as long as they are not within 9cm of the enemy during the move.  This is a very useful option for moving up reserves or as in this case, running away!

10. The Swiss proved difficult to evict from the village

This was the point just after my unenthusiastic Swiss battalion suddenly decided they actually wanted to fight.  They watched as the 26th Chasseurs launch a death or glory charge against the Spanish line infantry and in a vicious melee rout them, mainly because they hit them while they were still deployed in line.  It was actually a draw but the phasing player wins draws and infantry not in square beaten by cavalry rout!  Spurred on by this display of elan they occupy the village and decimate the Spanish light Infantry facing them, reducing them to a tenacity of two.  In response Gary rushes the 5/60th Foot (The Royal American's Rifle battalion) towards the village.

The Swiss prove difficult to shift and a desperate fight ensues with the Spanish light infantry making an assault that weakens the Swiss but can't dislodge them.  More positive is the musketry of the Spanish Militia who close up to and then destroy the remnants of the Chasseurs.  It's the last positive act for the Spanish as their accompanying light infantry are destroyed by Swiss musketry.  It needs another turn for the 60th to avenge the Spanish losses  when they finally are able to close into rifle range and defeat the Swiss.  Still for an unenthusiastic unit the Swiss held the flank while the Surviving French head for the hills.

11. and just like that it is over. 
Two very battered French battalions literally head for the hills

The end came after 13 game turns (Seven and a half game hours) and almost the same real world elapsed time.  The British without cavalry cannot close down the retreating French and sunset is approaching allowing them to slip away in the dusk.  The French have held out for the same time they did historically but with higher losses.  I consider this an Anglo-Spanish Victory  with two Spanish Battalions lost v three French plus a cavalry detachment.

Conclusions after actually playing a game
Firstly and most important the rules give an enjoyable game with lots of decision points for both players.  Secondly, it feels like a Napoleonic battle to me.  Players have to consider things like when to change formation to line from march column, when to form square and the timing of when to do it.  For a simple set of rules they keep you fully engaged.  They are not perfect and some of the design mechanisms are different to those I might have created, but they work. I tend to test a a new set of rules by refighting a historical battle.  This allows me to see how the mechanisms cope with recreating the events and how closely the actual result is reflected in the game outcome.  I don't expect a 100% accurate match up but it shouldn't be wildly at variance with reality either.  This refight was a decent match up and where it differed I could see why that was. 

There are two things I have suggested looking at and one change Gary and I agreed on as the game unfolded.  The agreed change is that when battalions from the same brigade are following each other in march column and are in contact nose to tail (so akin to a DBx group) only one activation test is required that effects all units in that extended column, it speeds up play and seems logical.

The two potential changes stem from something that happened that seemed 'gamey'.  I was able to get the timing of deployment and shooting so that I could shoot, and them move back out of range.  That meant that the British had to advance to get into range but of course the game sequence meant that they can't then shoot as firing happens before movement.  I could have fired and retired several times if I had space without the enemy ever getting the chance to return fire.  As I say that seems like a 'gamey' tactic.  So some form of restriction on marching fire to the rear seems to be required.  After all in the real world time isn't sliced up so neatly into shooting time and moving time, there is just time and you have to decide how to use it.  I'm considering a reduced move for units that shoot or some form of interrupt fire as a solution but will play a few more games before deciding.  It may be that the fate cards will help or that this is an edge case that doesn't occur in most games, especially with C2 rules in play.

Lastly after writing up this AAR I began to wonder about all that running around at the double.  Some units seem to have spent all day doubling across the Portuguese landscape and apparently no one got so much as a stich!  I reread the rules and found we were not playing retreat moves correctly which would have stopped the French getting away so easily and reduced the need for the British to double so much.  I may come back to this issue after another test game.

Other than that I'm sold on V&F for Napoleonic's, how the rules match up to some of the other periods they claim to cover is as yet unknown.  I'd guess that for linear periods such as horse and musket and perhaps Pike and Shot games it should be fine.  Earlier or later I'm not sure about as yet.

Final opinion.  They are decent rules and worth giving a go.  Especially as they are free!

Friday, 6 November 2026

V&F - Roughly Rolica

I couldn't really spend all this time building armies and then not use them, so following my recent board gaming session Gary said he would like to try some figure gaming.  So here was a chance to put them on a table with an actual opponent, how could I resist.  I had to proxy some artillery bases as I haven't bought any of them yet but other than that the troops are all Commission Figurines MDF.  I, of course, made some changes to the Valour and Fortitude rules to accommodate the use of 6mm figures on single bases which changes some distances for moves and firing, but mostly the rules remain as written. 

For a first time try out C2 remains as in V&F (all that hard thinking time and then I go and ignore the results, how typical!).  I will trial them next time out, honest.  We used a fairly small table and kept things simple so a French rear guard action against newly arrived British Troops seemed to be a decent script. I based this on Rolica 1808 (roughly).  Around about a brigade sized force for the French with an attached small cavalry force from division trying to delay a British force of around four infantry brigades (remember these are smaller than their French equivalents though) including some Rifles.  It actually comes down to 

Off table Portuguese troops, or in this case Spanish (well I did say roughly Rolica and I don't have any Portuguese painted yet) are moving round the flanks trying to arrive to the rear of the French rear guard.  This is was Wellesley's (he isn't Wellington as yet) actual plan at Rolica, to either trap the French or to force them to retire.  The French have to play a careful hand balancing the need to delay the superior British force against the risk of being trapped and destroyed.

Order of Battle

Anglo - Spanish Lt General Arthur Wellesley

Wellesley's Centre Division of four brigades plus Negrete's Spanish

Hill's Brigade 

5th Foot (Northumberland)

9th Foot (East Norfolk)

38th Foot (First Staffordshire)

Fane's Brigade

5/60th Foot - Royal American Rifles, Light Infantry

2/95th Foot - The Rifles, Light Infantry (small unit only a half battalion present)

Nightingall's Brigade

29th Foot (Worcestershire)

82nd Foot (Prince of Wales Volunteers)

Craufurd's Brigade

45th Foot (Nottinghamshire)

50th Foot (Queen's Own)

91st Foot (Argyllshire Highlanders)

Artillery

2 Batteries of 6pdrs

Negrete's Spanish Brigade (off table at the start)

Cazadores de Antequera, Light Infantry

Provinciales de Badajoz, Militia

Regiment Reina, Line infantry

French General de Division Delaborde

Brenier's Brigade of Delaborde's Division

Brenier's Brigade

1/70th Line Infantry

2/70th Line Infantry

4th Swiss Line (unenthusiastic so factors reduced)

3/2nd Light Infantry

3/4th Light Infantry

2 squadrons 26th Chasseurs de Cheval

Artillery

1 Battery of 8 pdrs

Next post will cover the AAR of the battle

Thursday, 29 October 2026

It was fifty years ago today....

 ......well not exactly today but close enough for jazz.

Last week I spent three very enjoyable days with some of the alumni of Hull University Wargames Club, the 1973 - 77 vintage.  Some of them I haven't seen since leaving university or very shortly after.  Back then the club was a mix of figure gamers and hex map board gamers, especially the SPI monster games like War in the East.  In fact it was the golden age of SPI games in some respects which made life a bit harder for the figure gamers as everyone seemed to have an SPI game they were desperate to try out!. 

The group which assembled last week was from the hex map game side of the hobby so the three main games were all of that ilk, but we also played a couple of slightly odd card games, well odd to me as I hadn't played them before.  To be honest I was so wrapped up in the occasion I only took one picture so bear with me.  So it came to pass that a rather greyer and creakier (than last time we met) bunch of wargamers gathered together comprising: Stephen Thomas, Dave Harbud, Gary Derrick (our host), John Staniforth and John Digby.  Dave H had to leave before any serious gaming got started as he had a trip abroad planned but the rest of us were there for the entire three days.

On day one we played 'Spies' a 1980's SPI game, set in the late 1930's in the run up to World War Two.  It's a typical experimental SPI game from the period, with no combat result table, no dice and no hexes.  players deploy police units to locations in their home country who try to intercept incoming spies or hunt down emplaced ones.  You also have your spies who move around Europe trying to collect secrets from other player's cities.  There are also event cards that are played by each player each turn and which may grant benefits to your side but also to the opposition.  It's an interesting concept but slightly flawed as the lack of a random element means some aspects of face offs between spies and police can be precalculated based on the known values of the police and spies.  In fact it is possible by stacking police units to create locations where a spy cannot avoid detection and can only escape capture by playing a skill chit.  Still it kept us entertained for an afternoon.

This is the one an only picture I grabbed.  Exciting isn't it.

Day two saw us play a more traditional and rather newer game from 2013 called 'Hinge of Fate'.  This covers the Poland campaign of 1939 but with a twist.  the twist being that you can choose to also play a French intervention on the Franco-German border.  While this actually did happen it was a half hearted attack that quickly fizzled out.  In this counter factual version of events the French after delaying three turns (six days) actually make a proper assault.  This puts the Germans in Poland under time pressure to capture all the Polish cities and fortified hexes before French advances start to trigger random events.  Now I know Hitler believed that a vigorous assault in the west could have defeated Germany and ended the war before it got properly underway but the possible impacts of French success in the Rhineland seem a bit extreme in this game.  Still it was a fun game and went right down to the wire.  The Soviets came into the war on the allied side and then the following turn the French also triggered a coup in Germany, Hitler was killed (yay!) and Germany lost.

The bit of the map I was playing on, no wide open plains with Panzers for me!

Day three saw us trying 2025's SPI game 'Eagles of Rome 1: Caesar', we played the opening scenario Orchomenus 85 BC, Sulla's Romans versus  the Pontic Kingdom.  The initial deployment didn't favour the Pontics as they have a big army and a restricted deployment area.  Once the legionaries get to grips they almost always force retreats or kills which cause disruption to units behind the retreating/killed front line troops.  I quite liked the system but then again I was in control of the Roman infantry.  The Pontic players seemed much less keen.  So much so that after we broke for lunch we didn't return to the game and instead played a few hands of Bandito and  6 Nimmt instead.

Eagles full map, our game used area III making it similar to a Folio game

All in all a great few days of gaming and catching up on who had done what over the last 40 - 50 years (God but that sentence makes me feel old!).  Hopefully we won't leave as long before the next get together.

Monday, 12 October 2026

The Bots are back

 If my hit rates to the blog are to be believed one of three things is going on!

1.  I have become increasingly popular as a blogger

2.  There are far less blogs to read out there, or

3.  AI bots are trawling blogs for data to use in large language model AIs.

I have gone from barely crawling into the 20 - 30 hits per post to a steady 150ish and those hits are almost instant after I hit post!

I don't really think I have become better at blogging as unlike Mary Poppins I'm not "practically perfect in every way" and the content can't be that interesting to a general reader with no interest in wargaming. I also haven't noticed a major falling off of blog posting either, which leaves me to believe that the AI web crawlers are back.

Is anyone else finding the same thing?

Sunday, 11 October 2026

Looking at Command and Control again

In the comments in my first post about this topic  (You can find it here >Small but Perfectly Formed: Command and control in wargames.<) Rob pointed me in the direction of a long out of print set of rules which had looked at the same points I was mulling over.  These are 'Napoleonic Rules for a Large Scale Action with Small Scale Miniatures'.  The rules were published in 1980 and had come up with a set of mechanisms to cover pretty much the exact issues I identified.  No point reinventing the wheel I thought and promptly hunted down a copy on Scribd.  After a read through and some note taking I was in agreement with Rob, almost half a century ago the same issue had come up and been solved by smarter minds than mine!

(AI image) This is the chain of command...don't make me use it!

The rules use a variable bound mechanism which was in vogue back then and which has fallen out of use since but it doesn't make much difference to the C2 rules involved.  It listed change of situation triggers, possible reactions to those changes and who can act on the triggers.  It also gives guidance on ranges over which triggers can be identified.  The core concept is that command and control are exercised at separate points in the chain of command and no one  (other than the CinC) can simply issue orders to attack, unless it is for a counter attack to defend the subordinates formation.  

Each link in the chain of command consists of a superior who issues commands and a subordinate who must execute them but can determine how that is done.  Orders have to pass down the full chain of command between an officer who is entitled to give a command and the officer who executes it,  and that takes time.  Essentially this consists of time in transit and time to read and execute the order.  In the absence of new orders a formation simply gets on with the last instructions unless attacked when it is entitled to defend itself.  I rather like the simple underpinning concept of "If tell you to jump all you are allowed to do is ask 'how high'."

The basics of the rules are as follows.

1.  The game starts with the CinC writing orders for the overall objectives of the subordinate commands.  These are broken down by Corps, Division Brigade objectives as required.  I can see fun and games arising in multi player games where three or four players are acting as Corps or Divisional commanders and have to translate Army level orders to their own subordinates objectives.

2. These initial orders are followed unless a change of situation is seen by an Army, Corps or Divisional Commander.  Brigades and Battalions can only deviate from orders if forced to act in self defence when attacked.  In that latter case all they can do is defend and/or or seek new orders from above.  Only the CinC has full freedom of action.

3. Change of Situation triggers are restricted to ten cases, see the tables below.  Each one has a limited set of responses available (also shown on the table below).

4.  Most responses only allow the parent formation to change orders but that requires a message moving from them to the subordinate formation and in some cases vice versa all of which takes time.

5.  Units engaged in firefights or close combat cannot respond to changes in situation or seek new orders.  This means that generals need be able to see what is happening to their commands to be able to influence the fight as the units at the sharp end are locked in place.

Permitted Responses to a change in situation
These possible changes are not mutually exclusive.  They include options for both the affected unit and that units superior.  So (for example) the subordinate unit could go on the defensive and seek new orders while the superior commander seeing the situation could send orders to other units in response

Triggers and options

The rules don't take into account failures to follow orders correctly and other areas of friction as it seems to be assumed that orders are not open to interpretation and are followed to the letter.  While this may be the case in most situations there are always occasional  'outliers' where subordinates have ideas of their own, for good or ill!  They also don't appear to be written to cover Army through to Battalion chains of command or the freedom of action granted French Corps commanders (Q was that really a thing on a big battlefield or just while Corps were acting independently?)

That said, looking at the above I think I have enough to work with to create some simple C2 rules.  Lets see how it goes.


Friday, 9 October 2026

And just like that

 Like what you may wonder?  As well as what happened 'just like that'?  Or maybe not of course.  You may recall that I was bemoaning the lack of local wargaming opponents and saying how I had taken a chance on sticking my head over the parapet to ask on a local Facebook page if there were any local wargamers in my small slice of North Lincolnshire.   The answer appears to be no and that the nearest historical gaming groups are either in Hull or Grimsby.  As a result I resigned myself to solo gaming for the foreseeable future.

Well 'just like that' I had a message from an ex member of Hull University Wargaming Club firstly asking if the same chap who had been a member back in the mid 1970's.  The answer being yes I was indeed a member some fifty years ago.  It turns out the ex member (no names no pack drill applies as not everyone wants their details splashing all over the net) was still in touch with a couple of gamers from back then and that they had been getting together for games meet ups.  The amazing bit being he lives less than fifteen miles away.  As a result I have an invite to a three day gaming session later this month and I'm in touch with some friends I haven't seen in half a century!

I don't think it will be figure gaming as the people concerned were fans of the hex map strategy games especially the really huge ones.  War in Europe was a favourite although they did draw the line at SPI's Campaign for North Africa.  But hey a wargame is a wargame on a table with figures or on a hex map with counters.  Watch this space for a follow up game report towards the end of the month.

Thursday, 8 October 2026

The grand parade of recycled wood dust

Also known as MDF, a strange material made of wood fibres, resin and wax.  It contains Formaldehyde which is not a pleasant substance and sanding is not recommended as the dust is potentially hazardous,  On the other hand it does make some excellent miniature figures and it's cheap (a recuring theme in my thinking you will have gathered by now!).  Once laser cut and engraved by the talented Walt of Commission Figurines, painted and based by yours truly they create a rather nice effect for not a lot of time and effort.

As always with 6mm figures the trick is to paint for the overall effect of the unit once it is based up, rather than creating individual masterpieces.  This especially so with the MDF figures and I have realised that painting them in an almost toy soldier style works well.  To be honest there is almost no scope for traditional high lights and ink washing is pointless as there is nothing to pick out.  A little creative paining of brighter shades along arms legs and shoulders some darker creases on the legs is about the best that you could do an guess what?  At arms length it hardly shows up so I didn't bother.  Even if I did I'd limit it to the front of the front rank and the rear of the rear rank and perhaps the left and right files outer sides.

So having made my excuses for a only using a limited paint scheme, here's what the result looks like massed together.

The Anglo-Spanish Army as it currently stands


The gallant losers, er,  I mean the French

Last but not least I have my first unit of French foreign troops the 4th Swiss Line Infantry.  Included in the front line of the above picture.

The Swiss, they look better at table top distance


Swiss rear view

I ran out of grenadiers in bearskins so sneaked an elite in shako figure into make up the shortfall.  I'm quite taken with the red and sky blue jackets.

All for now the next post is about something completely different. 

Monday, 5 October 2026

White Paint Pens - part two

I tried the paint pens this week.  They are not the perfect solution but they are neater than my freehand, more consistent and a lot faster.  They do need a good shaking before each use otherwise the paint and medium separate.  I was hoping for a perfect 0.7mm or 0.5mm line and that isn't what I got.  In both cases the line is thicker as the paint spreads.  In fact the 0.7mm nib gives a narrower line than the 0.5mm as it has a tapered nib while the smaller nib is more like that on a fine liner pen.  I'd say the 0.5mm gives a line closer to 2mm while the 0.7 is around 1mm. As a result both need a bit of touching up after the paint dries but not a huge amount.  The paint goes on smoothly and dries quickly and most importantly is a good solid white even over a dark base coat like Dark Prussian Blue. 

Part painted and pre touch up on the cross belt, but you can see the coverage is good

With a paint brush I can get a better result than  the above about 25% of the time.  The problem is the other 75% of attempts!  I tend to be a bit messy with the initial coats anyway and tidy up any over painting at the end so touching up cross belts is no biggie.

After a tidy up

I shall persevere with the pens as I think that with more practice I could probably get a more consistent and thinner line. The main point is that overall I'm no worse with the pen than I am with the brush and it is a lot faster in use.  The time on touch ups is still less than the faffing about trying to get a brushed line right.  So for me pens are useful, if you are younger than me and have good eyesight and coordination the paintbrush may still be the best solution.


Thursday, 1 October 2026

Command and control in wargames.

I recently came across an interesting discussion on TMP about command and control (C2) in Napoleonic wargames (it's here if you want to read it [TMP] "Command and Control rules in Napoleonic Rule Sets" Topic).  Which of course got me to thinking about how this is handled in Valour and Fortitude (Spoiler Alert - it isn't covered in any detail).  For me the lack of any certainty in C2 is a key part of pre modern wargame period and as such should be included in most rule sets.  So of course I started tinkering based upon the ideas thrown up in the forum posts.  Oh it's worth bearing in mind that some of my posts are an attempt to clarify concepts I have in my mind by writing them down in way that other people (that's you BTW) can follow.  This is one of those posts!

I have written it down so there can be no confusion! Thirteen fish and chips but no salt or vinegar on mine.  Grouchy wants haddock, Ney wants sole and the rest are cod.  Ten mushy peas and three curry sauces, and bring the change back!  Do you understand the order?

As I see it the issues boil down to:

  1.  Who can give orders or change orders, 
  2.  What trigger events should allow the initial orders to be changed,
  3.  How many orders can be issued per turn per commander,
  4. What should those orders be,
  5.  How long do they take to get to subordinates,
  6.  How to model failures in arrival and mistakes in applying them,
  7. Who can only execute the orders.

Some or all of the above have variable answers based upon the level a game is set at of course.  A game set at army level may not use individual battalions to execute orders.  Instead it may only go down to brigade level.  On the other hand a game set at corps or a division level may go down the command structure to battalion level.  This also impacts the scope for initiative to be used as a battalion commander will see less of the battlefield events than a division command as he is busy at the down and dirty end of the fight!  That means that they see less events that might trigger a change of orders, its a kind of target fixation.  

So lets look at a full army level C2 position and go through it step by step.

1. Who can give orders or change orders
Obviously the overall commander can issue orders to any subordinate.  I'd also consider that at the other end battalion commanders have no scope to change their orders, they just have to execute them.  In between those two extremes things are a bit cloudier though.  Corps, division and brigade commanders are given an objective but have some scope to decide how to achieve that, although that reduces as you move down the chain of command.  I could see an argument for brigade commanders to be in same boat as battalion commanders

2.  What trigger events should allow the initial orders to be changed
Another obvious starting point here, if a commander isn't aware of a thing it can't trigger a change.  This is linked to my comment on target fixation.  The nearer to the fighting a commander is the less he sees of the overall picture.  Also the lower down the chain of command the less they should be focussed on anything beyond their formations objective.  I'm considering some kind of situational awareness limit on what a subordinate commander can react to.

3. How many orders can be issued per turn per commander and what should they be
How many orders can be issued a turn depends on how decisive a commander is and how long a turn length is being used.  Note that decisive is not the same as good, a commander can be decisive (i.e. quick to make decisions) and still get the decisions and hence the new orders wrong!  

As for turn length V&F doesn't define things like time and ground scale, which is an issue to my mind,  I had to do it myself based on weapon ranges in the rules compared to reality.  For 6mm figures I eventually settled in 1cm to 20 yards/paces/metres (I'm not picky at 6mm scales).  From that I could approximate turn length from movement distances.  Infantry movement tuns out to be around 80 paces/turn in line which using an average of British and French normal marching pace length and rate gives just under a 90 second turn!  For an army level game this seems far too short to me.  How I wish the designer had done some math rather than using what felt right (see my note at the end)! So lets fudge the answer and call a turn 30 minutes.  So that's how long a general has to digest information and spit out any changes to orders.  

Lets also decide that generals come in only five flavours excellent, good, average, poor and bloody useless (aka atrocious).  The better the grade the more new orders can be generated each turn.

4. What should those orders be
I'm on firmer ground here as I considered this topic when writing my pike and shot rules and one suggested solution on the TMP forum matches my view.  So initial and new orders should be one of the following:

Attack an objective [a named location or formation] then once that is achieved change to defend

2.       Defend [a named location]

3.       Manoeuvre [to a named location] if attacked this changes to defend.  This includes a retire order

4.       Reserve – Standing by awaiting an order 1-3  

5. How long do they take to get to subordinates
Another fairly straight forward aspect.  Calculate the number of moves for a horse at maximum move rate to go between general and subordinate and at the end of that number of moves the messenger should arrive.  Once the new orders should be with the subordinate roll a D6 on a 1-2 they arrive straight away on a 3-6 they are delayed dice again next turn.  Remember the subordinate doesn't know new orders are coming so doesn't know they are delayed or even that the messenger was killed on route.  If after double the transit time the message hasn't arrived the commander may resend an order as the aide has not returned and can be assumed to be wounded or dead.

6. How to model failures in arrival and mistakes in applying them
If no new orders arrive the subordinate continues to follow his previous instructions unless he is entitled to issue orders to his subordinates.  If he is at the end of the food chain tough.  Carry out the last order until the morale test lets you run away!  otherwise some kind of test to see if the subordinate has the brains to see a change is needed.  A poor or atrocious commander may also misinterpret orders.  So roll a D6; on a 1 take more aggressive action, on a 2-5 follow orders and on a 6 take less aggressive action than ordered.

7. Who can only execute the orders.
As with point one this depends on the level of action being covered by the rules.  For army level games I would suggest that Battalions have no ability to change orders so can only execute the order given.  All other links in the chain have to execute their orders subject to discretion on how to do that.  That discretion should reduce the lower down the chain a subordinate is.  For example a brigade commander might be allowed to keep and decide when to release a reserve but little else.  A division commander might be able to determine what each brigade shall do to achieve his objective but can't change the overall objective.  While a Corps commander (especially a French one) is entirely free to make any decision they see fit unless given a direct order to follow.  Allied Corps should be prone to doing their own thing especially if Spanish.

Next time I will try and put some flesh on the bones of this post by creating some rule ideas for C2 for V&F.

Notes
I found a rather useful article on line on march rates here > Napoleonic Infantry March Rates – Rod's Wargaming <.  The opinion of the author, based on Dundas' drill regulations of 1792 is that lines and attack columns did not march at different rates.  So that's a popular wargames rule trope busted.


Thursday, 24 September 2026

White paint pens

One of the trickier aspects of painting the MDF figures which have been occupying my time recently are the cross belts.  I'm over 70 now and the eyes are not as good as they were, so painting very thin white lines becomes a hit and miss task at best.  So I decided to try one of the newer technologies available paint pens for this.  After a bit of research (Ok two minutes reading Amazon reviews) I took the plunge and bought a pack of four from Pinturale Arts.  These are two each of 0.7mm and 0.5mm tipped pens which I hoped would create the fine lines I need for cross belts and the edging to horse blankets.  I have used permanent ink pens for a number of years but find that they are not always as light fast as claimed so I was not entirely convinced that these would do what they said on the tin.

These are they (or them?).

The pens them selves are quite slim so probably don't hold much paint but at under £10 for four that is less of a worry than with the more expensive makes.

Sorry about the image quality but, you know, a pen is a pen

To use them simply shake for 30 seconds and pump the nib a few times to prime it and off you go.  I tried out the 0.7mm nib and as expected the line was wider than 0.7mm but not by too much and once some of the ink had flowed it became a little more precise.  Coverage was good and it is easy to get a line unlike my attempts with a size 00 brush!  The label showing the nib size was hard to see so I took the precaution of writing on the barrels with a Sharpie so I can see what's what easily.  Once I have some more infantry ready to paint I will try the smaller nib on cross belts and report back.


Wednesday, 23 September 2026

Napoleonic reinforcements and painting confusion

 As mentioned in my last post I came home from holiday to find my order from Commission Figurines sitting on the door mat.  I wasted very little time before getting them sorted out.  Well I say wasted, does unpacking the car, taking suitcases upstairs, the washing to the utility room (AKA a cupboard with a washing machine and tumble drier) and feeding the dog count as wasted?  Don't bother answering Mrs E has firm views on these things and I'm not going to argue.  But sorted they eventually were.

The point of this order was to give the French something like parity with the British on a battalion to battalion basis.  I get less French infantry units from each pack than I do British as I base them with more figures per base, so I needed to balance things out.  Of course I completely blew that plan by also buying packs for creating British allies in the form of Portuguese and Spanish infantry.  Of course, it's the latter nation which is causing the painting confusion.

All of you Napoleonic War old hands will already have faced this particular problem.  It's the Spanish supply system, or rather lack of one that's the issue.  They had uniform regulations, but once the French controlled (and I'm using controlled in it's loosest sense here) most of Spain, Spanish uniform was, well, not particularly uniform!  I make it three sets of official uniform regulations, plus various ad hoc uniforms followed by at least one set of British supplied kit on top.  Most of which seem to have been in use at the same time or at least overlapped each other to a fairly large extent.  Oh how I have enjoyed researching the topic.  It's safe to say that my brain hurts at the moment.

First two Spanish Battalions one militia (brown coats) and one Regular Army (White)

I'm currently looking at the period before British supplies started to arrive in bulk, which was from around 1811.  So I finally decide that to aid identification old regular army and militia should be in white, but with a sprinkling of brown.  New volunteers and new militia should be in brown and later war units in blue coats.  Light Infantry will vary and any formed guerrilla units will be a hodgepodge of colours but predominantly browns.  Head gear will be Bicornes, round hats (the top hat looking things) or shakoes as required.  Bicornes for early war regulars and militia, top hats (actually stovepipe shakos as the brims don't show at 6mm) for local Junta raised militia and volunteers and French style shakoes for later war or units who pop up as wearing them early in the war.  All of which is probably subject to change as things progress across the painting table!

Rear view of the above.  The engraved detail is not bad at all.

From what I can see the engraved relief on the backs of the figures is created by laser engraving 'pecking' out small chunks of the MDF.  The detail is rather surprising if that is the technique used.  Flags are freebies from the the net sourced from M S Foy's excellent blog Prometheus in Aspic Prometheus in Aspic: Homebrewed Flags - more 1809 Spanish and another excellent site  'JJ's Wargames Blog' JJ's Wargames.  The latter being especially helpful with advice on uniforms for the Spanish.

Thankfully for the Portuguese hardly varied their uniforms at all probably as they had a decent supply system after 1808! 

Thursday, 17 September 2026

Back from the Lake district

Not that you probably spotted that I was away!  Mrs E and I took the caravan to a rather nice caravan site between Keswick and Penrith for a few days R & R.  No TV very little internet connectivity and no blogging.  It was very relaxing.  The weather was kind and mostly only rained at night.  There is something very soothing about the sound of rain on a caravan roof, as long as you are inside the caravan at the time of course.  Our dog enjoyed the experience of running around in Crow Park and swimming in a couple of lakes and almost everywhere was dog friendly.  If you are in Keswick I can strongly recommend The eatery next to the Lakeside Theatre the food is really good and they have a few dog snacks available.

Brougham Castle Keep

Another view of the Castle

On the military front we visited Brougham Castle (pronounced Broom, so I suspect JBM has had a hand in this).  Carlisle Castle was closed while were there as it was before 10.00am and we got engrossed in other stuff (More food actually I can vouch for the chocolate cake in the Tullie Museum cafe).  On the History front we made our annual trip to Castle Rigg Stone Circle and also took in Long Meg and her Daughters as well.

Long Meg herself along with Mrs E and Mabel

Other than that we walked, drank beer and ate more than we really should have done.  It was horrible, honest.

'Surprise view' above Keswick.  Derwentwater in the foreground.

On my return my order from Commission figurines had arrived.  This consisted of one pack of Infantry in Bicornes to be used as Spanish in 1805 issue uniform or as militia, one pack of French Line with Grenadiers in Bearskins to be used for Spanish Grenadiers and French Line (I mistakenly thought it was a pack consisting of just grenadiers), two Packs of Infantry in Belgique Shakos for use as Portugeuse in Barretinas, two packs of French line in Shako, and some strips of Skirmishers and generals.  The skirmishers all seem to be French looking but at 6mm after a paint job I doubt anyone will be able to tell what style of Shako is portrayed.

I'm already wondering which packs would be the best bet for additional grenadiers for the Spanish, but won't be ordering anything until I have painted the 600 plus new figures that just arrived!  Pictures of those will follow (eventually).

Wednesday, 26 August 2026

Painting is back to normal

For the last few weeks painting has been a chore, not because I lost my painting mojo but because the heat made the paint go off far to quickly.  I still managed to get things done but only by dint of avoiding trying to work at the hottest part of the day.  It was the same problem with glues for basing  blink and it had gone off!  But as of this last few days we have had some very welcome rain and temperatures are actually below the seasonal average so painting is back on.

However, to paint I need good tools and I'm reluctantly coming to accept that my favourite paint brushes are coming to the end of their useful lifespan.  I can't complain they have served me well for over a decade, but their ability to hold a point has gone.  These were my first Kolinski sable brushes and to be honest they were inexpensive, given their quality, at under £5.00 a brush.  I bought some brushes from Rosemary and Co a few months back and those are very nice but I bought too many size 1 and not enough zero's or smaller.  I have to say though that I am impressed with them so far, as the points hold well even after a lot of use, and they clean fairly easily.

In respect of my painting output I have had a lot of MDF come across the painting table in the shape of the Commission Figurines Napoleonic stuff I bought at Joy of Six.  I have painted all of the British Foot I bought there, most of the French and I'm now working on some of the French mounted Dragoons.  Finding uniform details, especially for mounted types, has been a steep learning curve for someone like me with only a passing interest in the period prior to starting this project.  I used to have a hardback Osprey compilation on French Napoleonic Cavalry a few years ago but foolishly, I got rid of it as Napoleonic's were not my thing ....Doh!  Note to self never throw away reference material.


Thursday, 20 August 2026

Valour and Fortitude updates

Just a quick heads up to say that the updated version of Valour and Fortitude (Version 4) is now available to down load from the Perry Miniatures website.  I have read through it and the changes are fairly minor with one exception.  Skirmishers are now automatically treated as deployed which is dealt with by giving an extended shooting range to eligible units. That means that many units now have a short and long range band rather than a single range band. Units which opt to use volley fire use the short range as they are considered to recover skirmishers first before firing (well shooting your own lads is unsporting).  Artillery also has two range bands, the short one to represent the use of cannister. Some other rules have been clarified, to deal with some issues the player base brought up.    The one exception to minor tweaking is the big reduction in shooting values for Napoleonic troops. Units which might have had a shooting factor of 3 or 4 now have a factor of 1 or 2!  This change seems to be to reflect the use of very short range fire which is part of the close assault combat.  In this it is doing the same thing Altar of Freedom does and considering assaults as a mix of short range fire fights and bayonet charges.

I don't think the changes change my view of the rules as being what I'm looking for they are still fairly simple but have subtleties hidden in the special rules for each army.

On the painting front I now have eight battalions of British painted and based along with five of French. I have French Dragoons on the painting table so I'm nearly ready for a test game. The British are line infantry with a half battalion of rifles, while the French are three Line and two Light battalions.  I have placed an order for more figures to include some that will become Portuguese and some skirmishers and commanders.

Now me being me and being unable to help myself I have made a couple of changes to the rules as written (in keeping with the spirit of the rules though, honest!).  Firstly I'm basing battalions on a single 60 x 30 mm  base.  Secondly I'm using slightly less figures per battalion than the minimum that the rules recommend.  It doesn't make a huge difference as the rules don't count figures other than to consider if a battalion is larger or smaller than the norm.  My British have 20 figures in two ranks, while the French have 30 in three ranks.  This makes depicting open order tricky so to do that I will add a 60x 15mm base of open order figures to the front of the battalion to show that status.  For march columns I will just place a marker showing the front of the column and put the battalion base at right angles to normal so the 30mm edge becomes the front.  While that means that the figures would be facing the wrong way it is a quick fix until I mount some figures in a column formation.  I'm not sure how the rules deal with the various different attack columns frontages yet but I will get my head around it eventually.  For the moment to depict an attack column I will place the 60 x 15 base at the rear of the unit. I am slowly learning about the period as before Joy of Six I didn't know that attack columns could even be on different frontages or when they were used.

One other thing I have learned is that you get an awful lot of infantry for £4.00.  Even with base costs and estimated painting and texturing costs the troops below came in at just under £6.00 all in.  Skirmish bases are not textured yet as I need to add some firing skirmish figures to each base, which should be with me in the next few days.  Flags are home printed and slightly over scale.  MDF bases from Warbases and flock, sand and glue from my existing supplies.

£4.00 for two packs of infantry gives me this!

Best Napoleonic fact I have learned so far, is that Marshall Massena lost the battle of Bussaco because he was too distracted to coordinate the attacks of his three divisions.  The reason he was distracted?  His mistress was flaunting herself topless in a hussar uniform!  I suppose that would do it.  I haven't learned which regiment of Hussar's uniform it was though.


Friday, 31 July 2026

Thoughts on ...Valour and Fortitude Napoleonic rules

Yes, alright it's yet another new rabbit hole, I know I promised not too, but they were free.  You know free, my favourite price point and all that.  It's Napoleonic's that historical period that I don't do, except that now there is a distinct possibility that I'm going to be doing them.  In my defence I'm doing it on the cheap and in 6mm (well you have to be able to see some of the uniforms) but I haven't become a button counter, honest.

The rules don't come as a book so there is no front cover to show you!

You know how it is, the figures looked nice at Joy of Six, they were cheap, oh so cheap and just one purchase couldn't hurt, could it?  Next thing you know I'm looking up Italian uniforms for the Peninsula War.  Which are white, by the way, I mean which genius thought that one up?  How did they ever think they could keep them white in the field, what with black powder weapons, and mud and blood and such like.  Mind you it will make painting them easy when I get to them.

On a slightly less over-excited topic though: the rules.  As you might know I have tried Napoleonic's a couple of times and simply couldn't find a rule set that clicked with me.  So while I was wondering what to do with nearly 400 MDF figures I started searching.  A couple of sets caught my eye but none of them were quite what I wanted.  Then I hit on Valour and Fortitude (lets call it V&F going forward) they use battalions as the combat formations but can be played with brigades as the combat unit with very little change and others have done that with no problems.  They have the right level of granularity for me and I could download them for free so if I find I don't like them all I have wasted is some printer paper and ink.

The rules are fairly simple, the core mechanisms are contained in four pages (three really as the first page is just the definitions), plus a page for a QRS and another two for optional rules, even then most of the optional rules cover changes for different scales.  On top of which, each army has a separate two page list of unit types, unit sizes and special rules, plus a fate table.  Game play is IGOUGO, with dice controlled brigade activations, the play sequence is Fate > Fire >  Action > Melee.

The fate phase is where the fate table comes in.  This is a set of thirteen events or traits that are triggered by drawing a playing card each turn.  Some are used at once others can be held onto and used in a later turn.  The effect of the cards is not huge and doesn’t look like it would have a huge impact on the game play.   Next up is shooting and units which have now decide to  shoot cannot take an action in the next phase.   The action phase is where units may choose to move, reform, double, retreat, assault or rally.  Any action requires the unit to pass an action test, although some fate cards can overrule this.  Double is used to bring reserves forward and does what the name suggests, allows a longer move.  Reforms allow changes of direction and or formation and can be combined with movement, while rallies can remove hits.

I keep reading that the rules feel like Black Powder light, but can’t comment to that having never played Black Powder.  All fairly straight forward really.  It's the Army sheets which add the granularity and flavour.  These cover most of the popular Napoleonic armies and minor nations, plus ACW, AWI and British Civil Wars. The rules and all the other free stuff can be downloaded from here Valour & Fortitude - Perry Miniatures.  These are currently (Late July 2026) the 2nd edition, version 3.1 but there is an update to Version 4 due any day now.

As soon as I have enough troops painted and based I will run a solo test game with my usual explanatory sub sections.  That may be a while as so far I have painted four French battalions and only one British one, no cavalry or artillery.  In fact I haven't even bought any artillery yet!